500 Harbor Cove Circle, Longboat Key
+19416772620
EXP REALY LLC
Longboat Key is a long, skinny island between the Gulf and Sarasota Bay, with one road running down the middle and a bridge at each end. Most people who fall for it fall for the same thing. It's quiet on purpose.
That's not an accident. Since 1984, any increase in density on the island has needed a vote of the residents. So you don't get the wall of high-rises you see on other islands. "Keep Longboat Longboat" is something you'll actually hear people say.
The north end is the old fishing village. It was called Longbeach before the island had a town, and it still has the cottages, the big trees and a slower, walkable feel. Mar Vista has been sitting on the bay there since the 1910s.
The middle and south end are where you'll find most of the Gulf-front condo buildings, Bay Isles, the Longboat Key Club golf courses and the St. Regis. Cross the New Pass bridge and St. Armands Circle is a few minutes away for dinner and shopping.
One thing most people don't know: the county line runs right through the island. The north end is Manatee County and the south end is Sarasota County. That changes your tax bill and which school district you're in, so it's worth knowing which side a home is on.
I'm going to be straight with you, because this is where the island earns your trust or doesn't.
Hurricane Helene in 2024 was a water storm here, and a lot of homes took on surge. The island is coming back, but that history matters when you buy. Before you're under contract, get a flood insurance quote and ask for the elevation certificate. On older homes, ask what the home's elevation means for future remodels, because big renovations in a flood zone can trigger rules that require bringing the whole house up to current code.
If you're looking at a condo, the building matters as much as the unit. Every condo building on the island that needed a structural inspection passed. But passing isn't the whole story. Florida now requires buildings to fully fund their reserves, and that's pushing dues up in some buildings. Ask for the reserve study and any planned assessments before you write an offer, not after.
If you plan to rent it out, know the rule first. Homes in residential zones here can't be rented for less than 30 days. Check with the town on the specific property.
If you're financing, talk to a lender early. Condo approval, flood insurance and second-home rules all show up in the numbers, and it's a lot easier to know that going in.
Below are the waterfront homes and condos on Longboat Key at $1.5M and up, updated straight from the MLS. If one catches your eye, or you just want to talk through which end of the island fits you, reach out. No pressure, I'm happy to walk you through it.
Get instant property value now!
Get instant property value now!